Guide

Paralegal vs legal assistant vs case manager: who does what

What paralegals, legal assistants and case managers each do at a law firm, how the titles overlap, what each costs in-house, and which one to hire first.

Short answer: a paralegal prepares legal work for an attorney to review, a legal assistant runs the administration around the cases, and a case manager keeps open files moving and clients informed. Many firms use the titles loosely, so define the job by its tasks, not its name.

The three roles side by side

ComparedParalegalLegal assistantCase manager
Main jobPrepares legal work for attorney reviewRuns the administration around the casesKeeps open files moving and clients informed
Typical tasksDrafting from templates, record summaries, discovery, filing prepCalendars, correspondence, documents, data entry, billing supportClient updates, records and bills requests, appointments, deadlines
Works mostly withAttorneys and the fileAttorneys, staff and the systemsClients, providers and the file
Common inEvery practice areaEvery practice areaPersonal injury and workers’ compensation, and other high-volume practices
Our monthly price, full-time$2,995–$3,395$2,395$2,895

Paralegal

A paralegal does substantive legal work that an attorney delegates and reviews: first drafts of pleadings, discovery and letters from the firm’s templates, summaries of medical records and depositions with page references, organizing discovery, and preparing filings and exhibits. The attorney still gives the legal advice, signs and appears. Hire a paralegal when your attorneys spend their days on preparation they could review instead.

Legal assistant

A legal assistant handles the administration that every case generates: attorney calendars, shared inboxes, routine correspondence, formatting and saving documents, entering case data and handling e-signatures. Some firms call this role a legal secretary. Hire a legal assistant when attorneys and paralegals lose hours to scheduling, email and paperwork.

Case manager

A case manager owns the progress of open files between intake and resolution: regular client updates, records and bills requests and follow-up, tracking treatment and appointments, calendaring deadlines and keeping the file complete. The role is most common in personal injury and workers’ compensation, where firms carry many open files at once. Hire a case manager when clients call asking for updates, records arrive late and files stall.

Where the titles overlap

The government groups paralegals and legal assistants together in one occupation, and many firms use the titles interchangeably. Some firms’ “case managers” do paralegal work, and some “legal assistants” manage cases. That is why a job description should list the tasks. Our job description templates do that for each role.

Government occupation (BLS code)U.S. median payCalifornia median payClosest to
Paralegals and legal assistants (23-2011)$62,890$77,390Paralegal, case manager
Legal secretaries and administrative assistants (43-6012)$55,570$62,860Legal assistant

Pay: U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, Occupational Employment and Wage Statistics, 2025 medians, via O*NET OnLine. Benefits and payroll costs: wages and salaries were 70.0% of private employers’ compensation costs in June 2026 (BLS), so total cost ≈ pay ÷ 0.70.

Which one to hire first

Start where the firm is losing the most. If new clients are slipping away, the first hire is usually intake, not any of these three. If files are stalling, start with a case manager. If attorneys are buried in drafting, a paralegal; if they are buried in admin, a legal assistant. Our three-question picker gives a starting point, and the cost calculator compares any of these roles in-house with a remote seat.

Tell us who you need. We’ll show you who’s available.

A short call covers the role, the hours, your software and your budget. You interview everyone before anyone starts, and you pay nothing until they do.