Guide
Law firm intake response time: what the data shows and how to fix it
In Clio’s 2024 secret-shopper study, two in three law firms never answered an email from a prospective client. What that means for intake, and six fixes.
Short answer: when researchers contacted law firms as prospective clients in 2024, most firms never replied to the email and almost half could not be reached by phone. Both numbers were worse than five years earlier. The fix is not complicated: a person who answers during business hours, a rule for missed calls and web leads, and a log that lets you check your own numbers.
Who wrote this. Legal Staffing Pros places dedicated intake specialists with law firms, so we have a stake in this topic. The figures below come from Clio’s published research, linked at the end; the fixes work whoever does your intake.
What the secret-shopper study found
For its 2024 Legal Trends Report, Clio repeated a study it first ran in 2019: researchers contacted law firms the way a prospective client would, by email and by phone, and recorded what happened.
Share of firms contacted that responded. Source: Clio Legal Trends Report secret-shopper studies.
- Email: of the 500 firms emailed, 33% responded, down from 40% in 2019.
- Phone: 40% of firms answered the call, down from 56% in 2019. Counting callbacks, 48% of firms were effectively unreachable by phone.
Those results come from a sample of firms, not from any one firm. Yours may do better or worse; the only way to know is to measure, which is the last fix below.
Why it matters more for injury and workers’ comp firms
A person who was hurt in a crash or at work is often contacting more than one firm, and has questions that feel urgent to them. An unanswered call or an email that sits overnight is a lead that the next firm on the list gets to first. For a firm that pays for advertising, every missed inquiry is also money already spent.
Spanish-speaking callers add a second risk: the call is answered, but by someone who can’t hold the conversation. That inquiry is lost just as surely as one that went to voicemail.
Six fixes
- Put a person on the phone during business hours. Not a voicemail tree, and not an attorney between hearings: someone whose job is to answer new inquiries.
- Set a rule for missed calls. Every missed call gets a callback within a set time, and someone owns it. Write the rule down.
- Treat web forms and emails like calls. The study’s email numbers were worse than its phone numbers. A web lead should be called back, not just answered by email, while the person is still at their screen.
- Decide what happens after hours. Choose on purpose: a voicemail that promises a callback time and keeps the promise, an answering service for overflow, or extended coverage. Our guide to answering services versus a dedicated receptionist compares the costs.
- Use a script. Every caller should get the same screening questions in the same order, in their language. Our free bilingual intake script is a starting point.
- Log every inquiry, then secret-shop yourself. Record the source, time, outcome and next step of every inquiry. Once a month, have someone call and email your firm as a prospective client, after hours as well as during, and time the response.
Who should own intake
Intake works best as a job, not a task squeezed in around other work. In a small firm that is often one dedicated person; in a firm running heavy advertising, it can be a small team covering longer hours. Whoever owns it, the measure is the same: how quickly every inquiry gets a real answer, and whether the outcome is recorded.
If you’re weighing a dedicated hire, see the intake specialist role (Spanish and English, $2,495 a month full-time) or book a call.
Sources
Clio, 2024 Legal Trends Report press release (secret-shopper results for 2024 and 2019), read November 15, 2026. Coverage of the same findings: Above the Law, October 2024.